Many products on this page are from partners who compensate us. This doesn't influence our ratings. Our opinions are our own.
Investing · Rankings
Best Robo-Advisors of 2026
By Sophie Brown, Senior Finance Editor
Updated Jul 19, 2026
Fact-checked Jul 19, 2026
16 min read
Wealthfront ranks first among the five automated-investing services reviewed by DollarScout in 2026. Its 0.25% annual advisory fee, $500 Automated Investing minimum, diversified customizable portfolios, automatic rebalancing, and tax-loss harvesting for taxable accounts form the clearest complete robo-adviser package in this set. E*TRADE Core Portfolios ranks second for a Morgan Stanley-backed hybrid path, Robinhood Strategies is third for a $50 minimum and 0.25% fee, Acorns is fourth because excellent small-deposit automation carries a flat subscription that is expensive on small balances, and M1 ranks fifth as a useful self-directed automation alternative rather than a robo-advisor.
This page reviews five products in DollarScout's existing investing catalog. It is not an exhaustive market census; Betterment, Fidelity Go, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, Vanguard Digital Advisor, SoFi Automated Investing, Webull Advisors, and others may warrant comparison. Excluding them from the scored set is not a negative recommendation. DollarScout reviewed official pricing, client agreements, portfolio, tax, account, transfer, and regulatory material on July 19, 2026. We did not open accounts, answer risk questionnaires, inspect recommended portfolios, transfer tax lots, contact advisers, or measure actual returns.
$500 for Automated Index Investing, Automated Bond Portfolio, and Automated Bond Ladder; $5,000 for standalone S&P 500 Direct or Nasdaq-100 Direct; $1 for Stock Investing and Cash under their rules
$0 to open a standard self-directed brokerage or eligible IRA; Core Portfolios requires $500, and direct fractional buys require at least $5 in eligible Reg-NMS securities
$0 for a self-directed brokerage account; eligible fractional stock and ETF orders can start at $1, while Robinhood Strategies requires $50
No account minimum; $5 is required to begin investing or make an ordinary one-time or recurring investment
$100 initial deposit for individual, joint, custodial, and crypto accounts; $500 for Traditional, Roth, and SEP IRAs; $5,000 for trust accounts; cash accounts have separate rules
Commissions
0.25% annual advisory fee for Automated Index Investing; underlying fund expenses apply, while specialized portfolios and Stock Investing use separate published schedules
$0 online eligible U.S.-listed stock, ETF, mutual-fund, and options commissions; options are $0.65 per contract or $0.50 with 30+ qualifying quarterly trades, while OTC, bonds, futures, crypto, broker assistance, and other services have separate prices
$0 commission on eligible U.S. stocks, ETFs, and stock/ETF options; regulatory fees apply, index options add a $0.50 contract fee or $0.35 with Gold plus exchange fees, and other products have separate schedules
Bronze $3/month, Silver $6/month, and Gold $12/month; no separate transaction fee for Acorns-facilitated investments, while ETF expenses and other disclosed product charges still apply
No trading commission on eligible stock and ETF trades, but a $3 monthly Platform or IRA Fee applies unless waived by $10,000 in total M1 assets or an active Personal Loan; regulatory, closure, transfer, ADR, crypto, borrowing, and other fees can apply
Product Type
Digital investment adviser offering automated ETF portfolios, tax-loss harvesting, direct indexing, bond strategies, stock investing, planning tools, and a partner-bank cash sweep account
Full-service self-directed and managed brokerage from Morgan Stanley with taxable, retirement, custodial, business, futures, banking, and advisory account choices
Mobile-first self-directed brokerage with IRAs, joint and custodial accounts, separate crypto and futures products, Robinhood Legend, Gold, and optional Robinhood Strategies managed portfolios
Subscription financial-wellness app combining managed ETF portfolios, Round-Ups, recurring investments, IRAs, checking, and plan-dependent savings, match, family, and customization features
Automated self-directed stock and ETF portfolio platform using customizable Pies, recurring deposits, Dynamic Rebalancing, and scheduled trade windows, with separate cash, crypto, and borrowing products
Standout feature
0.25% fee with a clearly disclosed $500 minimum
$500 minimum and straightforward 0.30% fee
$50 managed-account minimum
$5 start with strong recurring and Round-Ups behavior tools
Flexible target-weight Pies and recurring automation
Detailed reviews
In-depth look at every product on our list.
Best Overall · Editor's Choice
1
Ranked #1
Wealthfront
★★★★⯨4.3/54.3
DollarScout rating
WEA
Wealthfront
Best complete automated investing system
Wealthfront offers the clearest complete robo-adviser package in this group: a $500 Automated Investing minimum, 0.25% advisory fee, diversified customizable portfolios, rebalancing, dividend reinvestment, and tax-loss harvesting in eligible taxable accounts. Direct Indexing begins at $100,000, provider tax studies are not guarantees, and digital-first advice does not replace complex human planning.
$500 for Automated Index Investing, Automated Bond Portfolio, and Automated Bond Ladder; $5,000 for standalone S&P 500 Direct or Nasdaq-100 Direct; $1 for Stock Investing and Cash under their rules
Commissions
0.25% annual advisory fee for Automated Index Investing; underlying fund expenses apply, while specialized portfolios and Stock Investing use separate published schedules
Product Type
Digital investment adviser offering automated ETF portfolios, tax-loss harvesting, direct indexing, bond strategies, stock investing, planning tools, and a partner-bank cash sweep account
Standout features
0.25% fee with a clearly disclosed $500 minimum
Automatic rebalancing and taxable-account tax-loss harvesting
Customizable diversified portfolios and mature digital operations
DollarScout's take
Wealthfront offers the clearest complete robo-adviser package in this group: a $500 Automated Investing minimum, 0.25% advisory fee, diversified customizable portfolios, rebalancing, dividend reinvestment, and tax-loss harvesting in eligible taxable accounts. Direct Indexing begins at $100,000, provider tax studies are not guarantees, and digital-first advice does not replace complex human planning.
Pros
✓0.25% fee with a clearly disclosed $500 minimum
✓Automatic rebalancing and taxable-account tax-loss harvesting
✓Customizable diversified portfolios and mature digital operations
Cons
✗Limited human planning for complex financial situations
✗Advanced direct-indexing features require substantially larger balances
E*TRADE Core Portfolios combines automated portfolio construction and monitoring with a broad brokerage, education, and Morgan Stanley ecosystem. The current minimum is $500 and the annual advisory fee is 0.30%, with tax-loss harvesting advertised for eligible taxable accounts. The surrounding institution adds service paths but does not turn the digital program into comprehensive personal planning.
$0 to open a standard self-directed brokerage or eligible IRA; Core Portfolios requires $500, and direct fractional buys require at least $5 in eligible Reg-NMS securities
Commissions
$0 online eligible U.S.-listed stock, ETF, mutual-fund, and options commissions; options are $0.65 per contract or $0.50 with 30+ qualifying quarterly trades, while OTC, bonds, futures, crypto, broker assistance, and other services have separate prices
Product Type
Full-service self-directed and managed brokerage from Morgan Stanley with taxable, retirement, custodial, business, futures, banking, and advisory account choices
Standout features
$500 minimum and straightforward 0.30% fee
Diversified managed portfolios with automatic monitoring
Integration with a broad self-directed and educational ecosystem
DollarScout's take
E*TRADE Core Portfolios combines automated portfolio construction and monitoring with a broad brokerage, education, and Morgan Stanley ecosystem. The current minimum is $500 and the annual advisory fee is 0.30%, with tax-loss harvesting advertised for eligible taxable accounts. The surrounding institution adds service paths but does not turn the digital program into comprehensive personal planning.
Pros
✓$500 minimum and straightforward 0.30% fee
✓Diversified managed portfolios with automatic monitoring
✓Integration with a broad self-directed and educational ecosystem
Cons
✗Costs five basis points more than the two 0.25% services
✗Human support scope and tax coordination require verification
Our pick for best low-entry percentage-fee adviser
3
Ranked #3
Robinhood
★★★★⯨4.3/54.3
DollarScout rating
ROB
Robinhood
Best low-entry percentage-fee adviser
Robinhood Strategies makes managed investing accessible from $50 at 0.25% annually. Accounts below $500 use ETFs, while larger accounts may combine ETFs and individual stocks. The low entry is compelling, but clients must distinguish the adviser from Robinhood brokerage and crypto, assess individual-stock exposure, price the optional Gold cap correctly, and account for the $100 outgoing ACATS fee.
$0 for a self-directed brokerage account; eligible fractional stock and ETF orders can start at $1, while Robinhood Strategies requires $50
Commissions
$0 commission on eligible U.S. stocks, ETFs, and stock/ETF options; regulatory fees apply, index options add a $0.50 contract fee or $0.35 with Gold plus exchange fees, and other products have separate schedules
Product Type
Mobile-first self-directed brokerage with IRAs, joint and custodial accounts, separate crypto and futures products, Robinhood Legend, Gold, and optional Robinhood Strategies managed portfolios
Standout features
$50 managed-account minimum
0.25% annual fee with clear monthly billing
ETF portfolios for balances below $500 and broader portfolios above
DollarScout's take
Robinhood Strategies makes managed investing accessible from $50 at 0.25% annually. Accounts below $500 use ETFs, while larger accounts may combine ETFs and individual stocks. The low entry is compelling, but clients must distinguish the adviser from Robinhood brokerage and crypto, assess individual-stock exposure, price the optional Gold cap correctly, and account for the $100 outgoing ACATS fee.
Pros
✓$50 managed-account minimum
✓0.25% annual fee with clear monthly billing
✓ETF portfolios for balances below $500 and broader portfolios above
Cons
✗App entity and product boundaries require careful attention
✗$100 outgoing ACATS fee and accrued fees can affect exit
Our pick for best habit and micro-deposit automation
4
Ranked #4
Acorns
★★★★☆3.9/53.9
DollarScout rating
ACO
Acorns
Best habit and micro-deposit automation
Acorns makes starting and continuing unusually easy through a $5 entry, recommended ETF portfolios, recurring investments, Round-Ups, automatic reinvestment, and rebalancing. Its flat $3, $6, or $12 monthly subscription is the decisive drawback: Bronze costs 7.2% of $500 or 3.6% of $1,000 annually before fund expenses, so small-balance users must value the bundle and grow the account quickly.
No account minimum; $5 is required to begin investing or make an ordinary one-time or recurring investment
Commissions
Bronze $3/month, Silver $6/month, and Gold $12/month; no separate transaction fee for Acorns-facilitated investments, while ETF expenses and other disclosed product charges still apply
Product Type
Subscription financial-wellness app combining managed ETF portfolios, Round-Ups, recurring investments, IRAs, checking, and plan-dependent savings, match, family, and customization features
Standout features
$5 start with strong recurring and Round-Ups behavior tools
Expert-built ETF portfolios, reinvestment, and rebalancing
Retirement and banking features bundled into current plans
DollarScout's take
Acorns makes starting and continuing unusually easy through a $5 entry, recommended ETF portfolios, recurring investments, Round-Ups, automatic reinvestment, and rebalancing. Its flat $3, $6, or $12 monthly subscription is the decisive drawback: Bronze costs 7.2% of $500 or 3.6% of $1,000 annually before fund expenses, so small-balance users must value the bundle and grow the account quickly.
Pros
✓$5 start with strong recurring and Round-Ups behavior tools
✓Expert-built ETF portfolios, reinvestment, and rebalancing
✓Retirement and banking features bundled into current plans
Cons
✗Flat subscription creates a very high percentage cost at small balances
✗No tax-loss harvesting and less portfolio customization than Wealthfront
Our pick for best self-directed automation alternative
5
Ranked #5
M1 Finance
★★★★☆3.9/53.9
DollarScout rating
MF
M1 Finance
Best self-directed automation alternative
M1 is included to clarify that Pies, Auto-Invest, recurring transfers, and dynamic allocation automate customer instructions but do not provide ongoing personalized advice. It is highly customizable for an investor who can select a portfolio. The $3 monthly platform fee below the current waiver, scheduled execution, lack of suitability monitoring, and absence of a managed tax-loss harvesting service make it an alternative—not a robo-advisor winner.
$100 initial deposit for individual, joint, custodial, and crypto accounts; $500 for Traditional, Roth, and SEP IRAs; $5,000 for trust accounts; cash accounts have separate rules
Commissions
No trading commission on eligible stock and ETF trades, but a $3 monthly Platform or IRA Fee applies unless waived by $10,000 in total M1 assets or an active Personal Loan; regulatory, closure, transfer, ADR, crypto, borrowing, and other fees can apply
Product Type
Automated self-directed stock and ETF portfolio platform using customizable Pies, recurring deposits, Dynamic Rebalancing, and scheduled trade windows, with separate cash, crypto, and borrowing products
Standout features
Flexible target-weight Pies and recurring automation
New deposits favor underweight holdings without automatic selling
Platform fee can be waived at the stated asset threshold
DollarScout's take
M1 is included to clarify that Pies, Auto-Invest, recurring transfers, and dynamic allocation automate customer instructions but do not provide ongoing personalized advice. It is highly customizable for an investor who can select a portfolio. The $3 monthly platform fee below the current waiver, scheduled execution, lack of suitability monitoring, and absence of a managed tax-loss harvesting service make it an alternative—not a robo-advisor winner.
Pros
✓Flexible target-weight Pies and recurring automation
✓New deposits favor underweight holdings without automatic selling
✓Platform fee can be waived at the stated asset threshold
Cons
✗Explicitly self-directed rather than an advisory service
✗$3 monthly fee can be expensive below the $10,000 waiver
Prices, methodology, tradeoffs, and the workflow each service actually supports.
How we ranked robo-advisors
The model weights Advisory Fit and Disclosure at 25%, All-In Cost at 25%, Portfolio Construction and Rebalancing at 20%, Tax and Account Capabilities at 15%, and Human Support, Operations, and Exit at 15%. A true robo-adviser must provide ongoing discretionary management under an advisory agreement; recurring deposits or algorithmic trade execution alone do not qualify.
We compare direct advisory or subscription fees and also consider fund expense ratios, cash allocations, spreads, transfer costs, tax consequences, subscription bundles, and conflicts involving affiliated funds or cash. No platform receives credit for tax-loss harvesting as guaranteed savings. Its value depends on gains, tax rate, portfolio losses, outside accounts, wash sales, holding period, and future tax rates.
Separate the advice contract from the app: compare the questionnaire, portfolio, total fee, tax behavior, human access, and exit process at the balance you expect to maintain.
1. Wealthfront — best complete automated investing system
Wealthfront ranks first for a mature, internally consistent advisory system. The current Automated Investing Account charges 0.25% annually and requires $500 to open and maintain under the May 2026 client agreement. Wealthfront recommends an allocation from questionnaire responses, invests the account, reinvests dividends, and rebalances as the portfolio moves away from targets. Customers can customize allocations from an eligible fund menu, but changes can alter risk, tax behavior, and tracking relative to the recommendation.
Tax-loss harvesting is included in taxable Automated Investing accounts. The software looks for eligible losses, sells the position, and purchases a correlated replacement intended to preserve market exposure. Wealthfront publishes a 2026 white paper claiming that its harvesting has often generated estimated tax benefits exceeding the advisory fee. DollarScout treats that as a provider study, not a universal result. Harvesting can defer rather than permanently eliminate tax, lowers cost basis in replacements, and can be undermined by purchases in an IRA, spouse account, employer plan, or outside broker.
Account-size thresholds matter. The broad ETF portfolio and standard tax-loss harvesting do not require six figures, but U.S. Direct Indexing currently begins at $100,000 in an eligible taxable Automated Index Investing account, while Smart Beta begins at $500,000. Those advanced strategies hold many individual stocks and introduce tracking, transition, and tax-lot complexity. A $2,000 beginner should evaluate the core ETF service, not marketing for a future tier.
At 0.25%, the advisory fee is approximately $1.25 per year on the $500 minimum, $25 on $10,000, and $250 on $100,000, before fund expenses and any other product costs. The percentage model scales cleanly, although the dollar fee grows with assets even when the software workflow is unchanged. A one-fund target-date solution could cost less for a simple retirement allocation.
Wealthfront's limitation is the digital-first relationship. The questionnaire and software drive the advice, and the service does not replace an adviser coordinating complex estate, concentrated equity, stock compensation, insurance, debt, or multiyear tax planning. It ranks first for an investor who wants documented automated management and is comfortable handling those broader questions elsewhere.
2. E*TRADE Core Portfolios — best full-service hybrid path
E*TRADE Core Portfolios ranks second with a $500 minimum and a 0.30% annual advisory fee, described as $1.50 or 0.30% annually at the minimum depending on account value and billing. The service uses a questionnaire to create a diversified portfolio selected by the advisory team, monitors it, and rebalances as needed. Socially responsible and other customization choices are available under current product descriptions.
The principal advantage is the surrounding institution. A customer can pair Core Portfolios with E*TRADE's self-directed brokerage, retirement accounts, extensive education, research, and Morgan Stanley resources. That does not mean every E*TRADE representative provides personal planning under the Core Portfolios fee. Prospective clients should ask which support staff can discuss the portfolio, whether advice is fiduciary for the conversation, and whether broader planning requires another service.
E*TRADE now advertises tax-loss harvesting for eligible Core Portfolios taxable accounts. The feature can create losses and replacement positions; it cannot know about every trade in an outside account unless the client supplies or coordinates that information. Ask whether harvesting is automatic or threshold-based, how replacement ETFs are selected, how restricted holdings are handled, and what occurs when the account transfers.
At 0.30%, the advisory fee is about $1.50 on $500, $30 on $10,000, and $300 on $100,000 per year before underlying fund expenses. It is five basis points more than Wealthfront and Robinhood Strategies. That difference is $5 per year at $10,000 and $50 at $100,000; service, portfolio, cash, taxes, and fund costs can matter more than five basis points.
Core Portfolios ranks second because it balances automation with a conventional brokerage ecosystem. It is weaker than Wealthfront for a customer seeking the most developed digital tax-management stack and weaker than a full human-adviser relationship for complex planning. Its best fit is an investor who values E*TRADE account integration and wants management without choosing each holding.
3. Robinhood Strategies — best low-entry percentage-fee adviser
Robinhood Strategies ranks third because the managed account starts at $50 and charges 0.25% of assets annually. Robinhood describes that as $2.50 per year for each $1,000, accrued daily and charged monthly. An account below $500 is invested in ETFs; at $500 or more, the portfolio may combine ETFs and individual stocks. That is a meaningful portfolio change around a small threshold, so clients should inspect the exact recommendation rather than assume every balance receives the same strategy.
Eligible Robinhood Gold members pay the management fee only on the first $100,000 in each managed account under current terms. Gold itself costs $5 monthly or $50 annually. A user should not subscribe only for the fee cap without doing the arithmetic: below $100,000 the cap provides no Strategies fee reduction, and at larger balances other Gold features, terms, and alternative advisers must be compared.
Robinhood Strategies is provided by Robinhood Asset Management, an SEC-registered adviser, and is separate from the Robinhood Financial self-directed brokerage and Robinhood Crypto. The managed interface does not extend SIPC protection to crypto, guarantee returns, or make every app recommendation fiduciary advice. Customers should read both the adviser and brokerage disclosures and confirm which entity holds the assets.
The service supports restrictions on some individual stocks under current documentation, but ETFs can still create indirect exposure. It can manage taxable and retirement accounts, subject to product availability and transfer rules. Outgoing ACATS from Robinhood currently costs $100, and fractional positions may be sold rather than transferred. Accrued advisory fees can be collected on closure.
Robinhood Strategies beats Acorns for small balances because a 0.25% fee is only $1.25 annually at $500, compared with Acorns Bronze at $36 annually before fund costs. It ranks below E*TRADE because its individual-stock use, app product boundaries, and shorter operating record demand more scrutiny, and because broader human planning is not the core service.
4. Acorns — best habit automation, expensive at small balances
Acorns ranks fourth despite offering one of the most effective behavioral systems for starting. Acorns Invest recommends an ETF portfolio, supports recurring deposits, automatically reinvests dividends and rebalances, and can invest linked-card Round-Ups after accumulated change reaches the applicable threshold. Current official material says there is no account-opening minimum and investing can start with $5.
The cost model is a flat subscription, not a percentage. As of July 2026, Bronze is $3 per month, Silver $6, and Gold $12. Bronze includes Invest, Round-Ups, recurring investments, an IRA, and checking under the current package. Higher tiers add features such as IRA contribution matches for a limited period, emergency savings, children's products, custom stocks or ETFs, and other bundled benefits. Eligibility, match, holding, and subscription terms need separate review.
Flat pricing is hardest on the small balances Acorns targets. Bronze costs $36 annually: 7.2% of $500, 3.6% of $1,000, 0.72% of $5,000, and 0.36% of $10,000, before ETF expenses. At $15,000, it is about 0.24%, roughly comparable to a 0.25% adviser if every Bronze feature has value. Silver and Gold require still larger balances or substantial use of bundled features to compete on investment cost alone.
Round-Ups are a funding method, not extra return. If small purchases cause more spending, the feature can undermine the goal. A $5 daily recurring contribution is easier to budget and audit than an unpredictable stream for some users. Acorns' expert-built portfolios can be sensible, but customization and tax features are more limited than Wealthfront's; Acorns' own 2026 comparison says tax-loss harvesting is not offered.
Acorns is best for a user who has repeatedly failed to start, will use the broader bundle, and can move quickly toward a balance where the flat fee is reasonable. It ranks fourth because a robo-adviser marketed to beginners should not hide how aggressively a $3 monthly fee affects a $500 or $1,000 portfolio.
5. M1 — best self-directed automation alternative, not a robo-advisor
M1 ranks fifth to correct an important category error. M1's own February 2026 guidance says it is not a robo-advisor and does not provide investment recommendations or monitor portfolio suitability. Pies, Auto-Invest, recurring transfers, dynamic allocation of new cash, and one-click rebalancing automate the portfolio the customer selects. They do not create an ongoing advisory relationship.
For a knowledgeable self-directed investor, this can be more customizable than a conventional robo-adviser. A Pie can hold chosen stocks or ETFs at target percentages, deposits favor underweight slices, and scheduled trading reduces the need to place each order. Model Portfolios can offer starting allocations, but the customer remains responsible for assessing objective, risk, expenses, concentration, and taxes.
The platform may charge $3 monthly unless the user maintains at least $10,000 in total M1 assets or has an active M1 Personal Loan under the current waiver. M1 says self-directed brokerage accounts do not carry commission or management fees, but the platform fee, regulatory, transfer, ADR, closure, and other charges can still apply. An account with $1,000 therefore pays the same $36 annual platform charge as a $9,000 account before the waiver threshold.
One-click rebalancing can sell appreciated holdings and create taxable gains. Dynamic rebalancing with contributions may reduce selling but does not guarantee that targets stay exact. M1 does not provide automated tax-loss harvesting comparable to Wealthfront's managed service, and trade windows limit execution timing.
M1 belongs on this page only as an alternative for readers who do not need advice. It should not be compared dollar-for-dollar with a 0.25% adviser without valuing the missing suitability assessment, discretionary management, tax tools, and advisory duties.
Robo-advisor comparison
Service
Minimum
Direct fee
Ongoing discretionary management?
Tax-loss harvesting
Critical distinction
Wealthfront Automated Investing
$500
0.25%/year
Yes
Included for eligible taxable accounts
U.S. Direct Indexing begins at $100,000, not $500
E*TRADE Core Portfolios
$500
0.30%/year
Yes
Available for eligible taxable accounts
Full-service ecosystem does not equal full human planning
Robinhood Strategies
$50
0.25%/year
Yes
Verify current portfolio-specific capability
Under $500 uses ETFs; $500+ may mix ETFs and stocks
Acorns Invest
$5 to start
$3/$6/$12 monthly
Yes for the recommended portfolio
Not offered
Flat fee creates a high percentage cost at low balances
M1 Invest
$25 Auto-Invest threshold
$3/month unless waived
No
No managed TLH service
Self-directed automation, not a robo-advisor
Compare cost at your balance
For a $1,000 account, a 0.25% adviser costs about $2.50 per year and a 0.30% adviser about $3, before fund expenses. Acorns Bronze and an unwaived M1 account each cost $36, equivalent to 3.6%. At $10,000, those percentage advisers cost $25 and $30; Acorns Bronze costs $36, while M1's current asset waiver may reduce the platform fee to zero if all conditions are met.
At $100,000, 0.25% is $250 and 0.30% is $300. Acorns Bronze remains $36 but offers a different service and feature set; M1 can be platform-fee-free but provides no advice. Robinhood Gold's fee cap becomes relevant only above $100,000 in a managed account and must be evaluated with the Gold subscription.
These examples exclude ETF expense ratios, bid-ask spreads, taxes, transfers, and opportunity cost from cash. Use the recommended portfolio, not a headline fee, to calculate the weighted underlying fund cost and cash allocation.
Inspect the questionnaire and recommendation
The SEC says robo-adviser recommendations depend on the information collected. Before accepting, record every question and answer. Does the questionnaire cover the specific goal, time horizon, withdrawal date, income stability, emergency reserve, high-interest debt, tax bracket, dependents, home, employer plan, concentrated stock, outside accounts, and willingness versus financial ability to lose money?
Compare the resulting allocation with the answers. Ask why each asset class is present, which index each fund tracks, whether affiliated funds are used, how much remains in cash, what triggers rebalancing, and how the recommendation changes when one answer changes. A label such as “moderate” has no standard allocation across providers.
Update the answers after material changes. A portfolio designed for a 30-year retirement goal may be wrong for a home purchase moved to next year. The software cannot infer an approaching withdrawal from silence.
Understand rebalancing and taxes
Rebalancing sells outperforming assets and buys underweight assets, or uses new cash and dividends to move toward targets. In an IRA, trades generally do not create current capital gains. In a taxable account, sales can realize gains, losses, or wash-sale complications.
Tax-loss harvesting sells a loss and purchases a replacement. The harvested loss may offset gains and, subject to tax rules, some ordinary income, but the replacement receives a lower basis. A purchase of the original or substantially identical investment in another account during the wash-sale window can disallow the loss. Automated advisers may not see a spouse's account, employer plan, or outside broker.
Ask how the service coordinates multiple managed accounts, identifies replacements, handles restricted securities, responds to withdrawals, and unwinds harvested positions during transfer. Consult a tax professional for material balances; marketing estimates are not a personal tax projection.
Human help and service boundaries
Determine whether support can explain only the app or can provide investment advice. Ask if a licensed adviser is available, by what channel, during what hours, at what balance, and for which topics. Portfolio advice, tax advice, estate planning, debt, insurance, stock compensation, and budgeting may require different professionals.
Read Form CRS and the Form ADV Part 2 brochure. Identify the adviser, broker, custodian, affiliates, compensation, conflicts, disciplinary information, voting policy, securities-lending practices, and business-continuity plan. Verify registration through IAPD and the broker through BrokerCheck.
Withdrawal and transfer test
Before depositing, simulate the exit. Can eligible securities transfer in kind, or must the portfolio liquidate? Are fractional shares sold? What ACATS or closure fee applies? Will proprietary or harvested positions transfer? How long can trading be paused? How are accrued advisory fees collected? In a taxable account, forced liquidation can be far more expensive than the stated annual fee.
For a near-term withdrawal, ask how the adviser raises cash, chooses lots, changes risk, and maintains the allocation. Do not wait until a home closing or tuition deadline to learn the settlement and bank-transfer timeline.
When a target-date fund may be enough
A low-cost target-date retirement fund can provide diversified allocation and automatic rebalancing in one holding. It may be available in an IRA or employer plan without a separate advisory fee. The tradeoff is less customization, a standardized glide path, and no individualized taxable harvesting.
Compare the target-date fund's expense ratio and holdings with the robo-adviser's total cost and services. Paying an adviser can be rational for taxable management, behavior, multiple goals, customization, or convenience. Paying for a questionnaire that recreates a readily available fund may not be.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest robo-advisor for $1,000 in this set?
Robinhood Strategies and Wealthfront both charge 0.25%, or about $2.50 annually before fund expenses, but Wealthfront requires $500 and Robinhood $50. E*TRADE is about $3 at 0.30%. Acorns Bronze costs $36. The cheapest fee is not automatically the best portfolio or service.
Is M1 a robo-advisor?
No. M1 explicitly describes itself as self-directed. Its software automates deposits and trades according to customer-selected targets; it does not provide ongoing personalized portfolio advice or suitability monitoring.
Does tax-loss harvesting guarantee lower taxes?
No. Results depend on market losses, gains, tax rates, holding period, outside trades, wash sales, future liquidation, and individual circumstances. It can defer tax and can create complexity. Provider studies are not personal guarantees.
Does SIPC protect a managed portfolio from losing value?
No. SIPC can protect eligible securities and cash if a member brokerage fails, within legal limits. It does not protect market declines, unsuitable advice, or promised returns.
Should I pay for a human adviser instead?
A human adviser may add value for complex planning, concentrated stock, business ownership, retirement withdrawals, estate coordination, insurance, taxes, or behavioral coaching. Verify credentials, registration, scope, conflicts, and total fee. “Human” does not automatically mean comprehensive or conflict-free.
Our methodology
How we scored every product on this list
DollarScout weighted Advisory Fit and Disclosure 25%, All-In Cost 25%, Portfolio Construction and Rebalancing 20%, Tax and Account Capabilities 15%, and Support, Operations, and Exit 15%. We reviewed documents but did not open accounts, answer questionnaires, test portfolios, or measure returns.
This review cycle used official product documentation, published methodology, current plan terms, and regulatory sources. Any hands-on or support-response testing is stated explicitly when performed. Read our fullmethodologyfor the complete scoring rubric.
DollarScout uses a privacy-friendly, cookie-less analytics script (Ahrefs) to understand traffic in aggregate. We don't sell your personal information and don't run ad trackers. You can review our Privacy Policy or opt out of data sharing any time.